|   | 
                 
                  
                    
                      
                      
                        
                          | 
                           
                          Committee on House 
                          International Relations Subcommittee on Asia and the 
                          Pacific  | 
                         
                        
                          | 
                          February 15, 2006 | 
                         
                        
                          | 
                            | 
                         
                        
                          | 
                            | 
                         
                       
                       | 
                     
                   
                  
                  
                  Mr. Chairman, thank you for inviting me 
                  to testify today on the important topic of China's Internet 
                  censorship. I would like to take this opportunity to brief you 
                  on how Radio Free Asia is fulfilling its 
                  congressionally-mandated mission to act as a surrogate for 
                  indigenous free media in China, how it has been aggressively 
                  developing new ways to expand its audience in China in this 
                  Internet age, and why its mission today is, if anything, even 
                  more important than when our station began broadcasting a 
                  decade ago. 
                   
                  Radio Free Asia first went on the air in September 1996. Since 
                  then the Internet has witnessed explosive growth in China, 
                  claiming more than 110 million users by official Chinese 
                  numbers. Radio Free Asia has, in the short span of 10 years, 
                  established itself as an objective source of information for 
                  the people of China, many of whom rely upon us daily for news 
                  of the latest events and trends in their own country.  
                   
                  Radio Free Asia has earned the trust of its Chinese listeners 
                  and has established a reputation for being a credible source 
                  and effective disseminator of information. When domestic 
                  Chinese media fail to inform, Radio Free Asia is there to fill 
                  in the gap. In the words of a Sichuan listener who telephoned 
                  RFA Mandarin service's "Listener Hotline": "Radio Free Asia is 
                  a beacon of hope for the Chinese people." This has become 
                  particularly vital in spreading lightning-fast news concerning 
                  cyber-activism and cyber-censorship. 
                   
                  I. RFA is Aggressively Covering the News of Cyber-Censorship 
                   
                  Radio Free Asia's recent coverage of Chinese cyber-censorship 
                  and its aftershocks includes the following: 
                   
                  1. In September 2005, Radio Free Asia was first to report the 
                  closure of the Yannan Forum, an online discussion site that 
                  had reported the controversy over a recall campaign by 
                  villagers in Taishi in Guangdong province of their elected 
                  village chief. Before the Web closing, Yannan received a 
                  warning from the government that no news about Taishi was to 
                  be posted on this site. News about Taishi was referred to as 
                  "harmful information." 
                   
                  2. In October 2005, RFA reported that two Web sites, Ehoron 
                  and Monhgal, in Inner Mongolia, were closed. These sites 
                  served primarily as a discussion platform for Mongolian 
                  students. When the site managers promised not to post any 
                  information on Mongolian separatism on the site, they were 
                  allowed to reopen in December 2005. 
                   
                  3. Beginning in June 2005 and continuing throughout January 
                  2006, RFA has been reporting on the highly popular Yulun Net 
                  Web site and its blogs' periodic closures. The Web master, Lee 
                  Xinde, told RFA that the most recently closed blog, Dahe, had 
                  more than 100,000 page views since September and was the first 
                  to report on the alleged bribery of the vice mayor of Jining 
                  in Shanxi province. He also told RFA that he is instructed to 
                  close down specific blogs by the authorities. 
                   
                  4. On December 6, 2005, Radio Free Asia was first to report 
                  the news that protesters were being shot by paramilitary 
                  police in Dongzhou village, near the city of Shanwei, in 
                  Guangdong province. Villagers there had been protesting the 
                  construction of a power plant on land that had been 
                  expropriated by local officials. According to witnesses 
                  interviewed by Radio Free Asia, more than a dozen villagers 
                  were killed, though the Chinese government to this day insists 
                  that only three persons died as a result of the crackdown. 
                  Radio Free Asia was able to break the news of these shootings 
                  because an eyewitness had called one of our bureaus, 
                  desperately asking for help. His exact words were: "Please 
                  tell the world what they are doing to us!" Despite a Chinese 
                  state media blackout of these events, RFA.org was able to 
                  provide continuous coverage and reach its audience through 
                  small proxy Web servers. 
                   
                  5. Also in December 2005, RFA.org published a video account of 
                  events in Taishi village in southern China, where villagers 
                  had been petitioning since July for the recall of their 
                  elected village chief over charges of corruption. Within days, 
                  a man turned up in a local cafe providing vivid details of the 
                  footage. "How did you get to see that video?" asked one of the 
                  patrons. "I access the RFA Web site via proxy servers," the 
                  man answered. He invited a group to his home where, behind 
                  closed doors, they all gathered in front of his computer 
                  screen to watch the video. 
                   
                  On that day, many people in China battling government 
                  oppression knew they were not alone 
                   
                  6. On January 2, 2006, RFA reported that Shenzhen in Guangdong 
                  province was the first city to use a new Web police warning 
                  system in China. When Web users log onto the Internet in 
                  Shenzhen and visit certain discussion forums, they see a 
                  pop-up figure of two police officers. 
                   
                  This figure leads to a warning page that instructs Internet 
                  users to comply with the law. RFA reported that users felt 
                  intimidated by the pop-up and feared that it acted as a 
                  surveillance tool. 
                   
                  7. And just a few weeks ago, on January 24th, Radio Free Asia 
                  was first to confirm the government's suspension of Bing Dian 
                  ("Freezing Point"), a popular and influential weekly 
                  supplement to China Youth Daily. In our interview, Li Datong, 
                  the supplement's chief editor, told us that simultaneously 
                  with the paper's closure, he was notified that his personal 
                  blog had been removed from a popular Web site, on orders "from 
                  higher-up." Radio Free Asia's initial report on this crackdown 
                  on political expression was soon picked up by more than 30 
                  major media outlets worldwide. 
                   
                  These stories, and many others reported by RFA, demonstrate 
                  that despite dramatic improvements in their economy, the 
                  Chinese people often pay a heavy price for exchanging ideas. 
                  According to Reporters without Borders, China is the world's 
                  leading jailer of journalists and cyber-dissidents. Despite 
                  the fact that its city dwellers can now sample pizza from 
                  Pizza Hut and savor lattes from Starbucks, China remains what 
                  former Soviet dissident Natan Sharansky has called a "fear 
                  society." As Sharansky explains in The Case for Democracy, "If 
                  a person can walk into the middle of the town square and 
                  express his or her views without fear of arrest, imprisonment, 
                  or physical harm, then that person is living in a free 
                  society, not a fear society. If a person cannot do so, that 
                  person is living in a fear society." By Sharansky's standard, 
                  or by any reasonable standard, China today is a "fear 
                  society." 
                   
                  Radio Free Asia has helped ensure a free flow of information 
                  into this "fear society" so that its people can learn what is 
                  happening in their country--including, importantly, what it is 
                  that their government does not want them to know. 
                   
                  Beyond the benefits to the Chinese people of having a source 
                  of objective news and a forum for communicating freely with 
                  one another, the potential benefits to the United States are 
                  considerable as well. The Rising China - both economic and 
                  military - has brought home to us the importance of providing 
                  this closed society accurate, unbiased news and information 
                  beyond what its leaders allows its people to have. 
                   
                  Authoritarian governments are heavy handed in controlling 
                  access to information. More complete information, and greater 
                  exposure to competing political viewpoints, help ensure that 
                  populations in closed societies are more likely to approach 
                  the outside world, including the United States, with an open 
                  mind. 
                   
                  Even where citizens of foreign countries are managing to 
                  obtain greater access to news from third parties, these 
                  sources are far from being substitutes for the work of 
                  entities such as Radio Free Asia. On this point, the Chinese 
                  government certainly seems to agree. Why else are they so 
                  aggressively trying to block access by the Chinese people to 
                  our Web site? And why do they devote so much effort and money 
                  to jamming our radio broadcasts? 
                   
                  II. RFA is Aggressively Expanding Its Audience in the Age of 
                  the Internet 
                   
                  RFA's Mandarin, Cantonese, Uyghur, and Tibetan Web sites have 
                  a unique connection to the people who live under Chinese 
                  censorship. They match rigorous reporting with lively 
                  interactive exchanges with their readers via email and message 
                  boards. Through cyberspace, as much as through the broadcast 
                  airwaves, RFA bears witness to the hope and despair of those 
                  who seek to exercise their right to free expression in China. 
                   
                  Audience research figures from Intermedia, an independent 
                  research firm, show there may be as many as 175 million adults 
                  in China accessing the Internet on at least a weekly basis, 
                  nearly as many as in Japan and South Korea put together. But 
                  the Web carries its own dangers. When Chinese readers go 
                  online, they do so under surveillance and often at great risk 
                  to themselves and their families. Rarely do they get a full 
                  picture; many sites are blacked out whether the users know it 
                  or not. The pages they visit are recorded, the content 
                  filtered, and their browsing patterns closely scrutinized. And 
                  the situation is not about to improve, as China continues to 
                  invest in the most advanced technologies for blocking unwanted 
                  material from blogs, emails, and Web sites. 
                   
                  The scope of China's Internet surveillance is daunting. 
                  Reliable figures are scarce, but reports speak of tens of 
                  thousands of Web police patrolling cyberspace, with 86 
                  journalists or Internet users in Chinese jails. Beijing has 
                  enormous resources directed towards Internet censorship. 
                   
                  Conventional wisdom has long held that the open nature of the 
                  World Wide Web and its free, accessible brew of cultures would 
                  "bring democracy to China." Today that view looks optimistic 
                  indeed. The question is not whether the Internet is going to 
                  change China, but rather how much China is going to change the 
                  Internet. 
                   
                  RFA bears the brunt of Beijing's censorship. If RFA is 
                  stymied, its Chinese readers are deprived of news that is 
                  immediately relevant to their daily lives. They lose a chance 
                  for the crucial input that can help them make informed 
                  decisions for themselves and their families and form opinions 
                  based on accurate and balanced information. 
                   
                  As a news organization, RFA operates in a highly unusual 
                  environment and maintains a unique relationship with its Web 
                  users. RFA must not only distribute its news, but must help 
                  its readers to outsmart the censors. We know we are catering 
                  to people who might have to read the pages using proxy servers 
                  or via encrypted transmission services. 
                   
                  We use all available avenues to reach out to new readers and 
                  strive to stay at the cutting edge of technological 
                  innovation. Our radio broadcasts educate our target audience 
                  on how to use proxy servers and other gateways. On the Web, we 
                  offer live streaming of our broadcast shows. We are constantly 
                  looking for ways to evade the Chinese censors. In October we 
                  started offering our news programs via podcast to multiply the 
                  number of distribution channels and make the content ever more 
                  portable. 
                   
                  The Internet anti-censorship program of the Broadcasting Board 
                  of Governors provides support for our efforts to break through 
                  the Chinese blockage of our Internet content. The BBG's Office 
                  of Information Systems and Technology works with industry and 
                  government consultant experts to find ways to keep information 
                  flowing to China through Internet portals. The emails are 
                  distributed by BBG to users in China, which in turn allow 
                  those users the ability to access RFA, VOA or other blocked 
                  sites on the worldwide web through the proxy sites identified 
                  in the emails. The BBG continues to monitor and utilize the 
                  latest technology to get through the filtering mechanisms of 
                  the Chinese Government. 
                   
                  By all evidence RFA Web users are not easily deterred. They 
                  share their fears openly about being observed and even 
                  threatened by the Chinese government. One of our Tibetan 
                  readers wrote on a message board last month how he drew a 
                  menacing reaction when he posted "10 famous sayings for 2005 
                  by Chinese leaders." "When I checked back," he said, "I 
                  received a threat from what I believe is a Chinese user. This 
                  showed how little China has changed over the last 50 years." 
                  But others wouldn't let him get discouraged. "Don't be 
                  intimidated," answered one of his message board buddies. "We 
                  are practicing free speech. Whoever wants to intimidate those 
                  who speak out will be condemned and lose the moral high 
                  ground." 
                   
                  RFA is also partnering with a courageous and growing online 
                  community of technical experts inside and outside China who 
                  help us get our newsletters out to the people who need them. 
                  With their help, we are creating a widening network of human 
                  proxies, so informal that it has no visible shape but is very 
                  much alive. Message boards, emails, blogs and instant messages 
                  pick up where the government has cut us off. Friends and 
                  family based in third countries post our articles on their own 
                  Web sites and then pass on the Web address. RFA news travels 
                  fast and well by fax, letters, phone, and word of mouth. We 
                  know that when it matters most, our information gets to its 
                  destination. 
                   
                  The hope of the Internet for societies such as China's is that 
                  it will help enable people to communicate and hear dissenting 
                  views through a medium that is more anonymous, and hence 
                  leaves them less vulnerable to government retaliation. In the 
                  case of China, democracy activists, rights defenders, and 
                  others with a degree of computer literacy are increasingly 
                  using the Internet to exchange ideas despite the fact that in 
                  exercising their digital rights they risk incurring the wrath 
                  of the country's cyber- police. This is no doubt one reason 
                  for the recent highly publicized demand by Chinese authorities 
                  that foreign technology companies agree to limit their search 
                  engine functionality as a condition for operating within 
                  China. The Internet in general and online forums in particular 
                  are critical to the growth of rights consciousness and a freer 
                  civil society in China. 
                   
                  In addition to reporting on issues such as the jailing of 
                  cyber- dissidents and the closures of Web sites, RFA.org has 
                  increased substantially its coverage of specifically 
                  Internet-related and Internet-driven topics. Our Mandarin 
                  service news scripts are sent to more than two million email 
                  accounts a day across China. Our February 1 report on US 
                  internet technology companies and China apparently struck a 
                  nerve with our audience, as it drew almost three times the 
                  number of page views that we witness on a normal day. The 
                  posting of the "Wild Pigeon" fable on our Uyghur, Mandarin and 
                  English web pages brought to thousands of people inside and 
                  outside the Uyghur Autonomous Region the allegory for which 
                  the poet and the publisher were imprisoned. The RFA Tibetan 
                  site has become a discussion forum for 164 topics of debate 
                  among Tibetans over the last 11 months and is now a real-time 
                  conduit for breaking news. 
                   
                  We are witnessing a profound change in China. That change is 
                  occurring not only in the economic and technological sectors, 
                  but even more importantly in the psychology of the Chinese 
                  people. Thanks in part to the flow of information that the 
                  Internet has facilitated, a growing number of socially aware 
                  Chinese have become loyal listeners of foreign broadcasters. 
                  At the same time, there has been an upsurge in rights 
                  consciousness on the part of the general public. 
                   
                  As a result, people are less willing to live in obedience, and 
                  some are taking to the streets to voice their objections to 
                  issues ranging from forced evictions to corruption to 
                  environmental pollution. The Chinese Ministry of Public 
                  Security reports 87,000 public disturbances across the country 
                  last year, up from 74,000 the year before. 
                   
                  Radio Free Asia takes great pride in its high-quality work, 
                  and in the fact that we provide our listeners across China, 
                  and those in the other East Asian nations to which we 
                  broadcast with objective and balanced information. As such, we 
                  serve as an example of a free press for our listeners. 
                   
                  In addition to bringing news and information to the Chinese 
                  people that they cannot otherwise access, Radio Free Asia, 
                  through news analysis and commentaries, aims to promote 
                  Internet freedom by impressing upon its audience that human 
                  rights include digital rights, and that freedom of expression 
                  in real time - in the actual town hall or in the virtual town 
                  square - is itself a fundamental right, as enshrined in 
                  Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. 
                   
                  Conclusion 
                   
                  In conclusion, I would like to reiterate that Radio Free Asia 
                  is ably and eloquently fulfilling its mission-providing 
                  journalism of the highest standard to East Asian populations 
                  whose governments aim to restrict their access to full, 
                  balanced, and objective news coverage. RFA, further, is taking 
                  maximum advantage of Web technology to deliver our reporting 
                  by every available means, including RSS feeds and podcasting. 
                  Every day is a new race for technological advantage at speeds 
                  too fast to handicap-and with some notable victories. 
                   
                  Nearly a year ago, thanks in part to pressure from this 
                  Congress, Uyghur activist Rebiya Kadeer was released from jail 
                  in the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region and exiled from 
                  China. On March 17, 2005, she was reunited with her husband in 
                  the United States. RFA recorded the moment in words and photos 
                  that we quickly posted on our Uyghur- and English-language Web 
                  pages. Barely 24 hours later, the children Ms. Kadeer had left 
                  behind in Urumqi had seen RFA's online coverage and excitedly 
                  told their siblings in the United States: "We saw our parents 
                  kiss!" 
                   
                  In a Chinese autonomous region with uniquely stringent 
                  Internet controls, where police keep close tabs on who speaks 
                  to whom, where any Uyghur jubilation prompts suspicion or 
                  worse, this simple digital photo of Rebiya Kadeer and her 
                  husband locked in a tender embrace, published online from half 
                  a world away, constituted a joyful triumph. 
   |